Abstract
The objective of this study is to experimentally evaluate two residential split heat pumps using low-GWP refrigerants, i.e., R452B and R454B, and compare the results against R410A. Each heat pump used the same model of two-speed scroll compressor, the same indoor blower and outdoor fan. However, they were distinguished by the indoor and outdoor heat exchanger types: tube-fin heat exchangers (TFHXs) in one case, and microchannel heat exchangers (MCHXs) in the other. The two heat pumps were extensively evaluated following the test conditions for two-speed SEER (cooling seasonal energy efficiency rating)/HSPF (heating seasonal performance factor) ratings.
In general, these results show that R452B and R454B are good replacement candidates for R410A for heat pump using tube-fin heat exchangers and microchannel heat exchangers. R452B and R454B led to lower capacities. In the TFHX heat pump, on average, compared to the performance of R410A, the cooling capacity of R452B is 96%; the heating capacity of R452B is 91%; the cooling capacity of R454B is 95%, the heat capacity of R454B is 89%. In the MCHX heat pump, the cooling capacity of R452B is 97%; the heating capacity of R452B is 97%; the cooling capacity of R454B is 98%, the heat capacity of R454B is 97%. With respect to cooling and heating seasonal performances, in the TFHX heat pump, the SEERs of R452B and R454B are 1.5% lower than R410A. HSPFs of the three refrigerants are identical. In the MCHX heat pump, R454B has 7% higher SEER, and R452B has 2% higher SEER than R410A; in heating mode, R454B has the same HSPF as R410A, while R452B is 4% more efficient. The compressor lubricant overheating issue of R452B and R454B, at low ambient heating condition, high stage, should be noticed.
