Abstract
Previous neutronic/thermal-hydraulic (TH) coupled numerical simulations using full-core TRACE/PARCS and SIMULATE-3K boiling water reactor (BWR) models have shown evidence of a specific “rotating mode” behavior (steady rotation of the symmetry line, i.e. constant phase shift of approximately 90° between the first two azimuthal modes) in BWR out-of-phase limit cycle oscillations, regardless of initial conditions and even if the first two azimuthal modes have different natural frequencies. This suggests a nonlinear coupling between these modes; otherwise, the phase shift between these modes would change at a constant rate during the limit cycle. The previous paper (“Part 1”) presented a series of results to examine this rotating behavior with a reduced-order model. The goal of the present study is to provide additional analyses of the predicted rotating mode behavior using higher-fidelity numerical modeling, as well as a physical explanation for why this mode is favored over side-to-side or other oscillatory behaviors from a TH perspective. Results are presented using TRACE and TRACE/PARCS for a small number of parallel channels, which confirmed that the conclusions developed from the reduced-order model remain applicable when applying a full two-fluid, six-equation, finite-volume modeling approach. From these results, a physical explanation has been put forth to explain why the rotating symmetry line behavior is preferred from a TH standpoint, demonstrating that predominantly out-of-phase unstable systems are most unstable when the variation in the total inlet flow rate is minimized (which minimizes the effective single-phase to two-phase pressure drop ratio) and that the rotating mode is the most successful in minimizing this total flow rate variation as compared with the side-to-side case or any other oscillation pattern. The conclusion is that the rotating mode will be favored for any out-of-phase unstable system of parallel channels with no neutronic feedback or relatively weak neutronic feedback. Previous analyses have indicated that systems with sufficiently strong neutronic coupling may favor the side-to-side oscillation mode over the rotating mode; this topic is left as a subject of future investigation.
